Contact me
  • Home
  • Why "This Game Of Games"?
  • What's Up With That Rooster?
  • The Old Blog
  • Henry Gratiot and Early St. Louis Ball-Playing
  • Baseball In The Illinois Country
  • Thoughts On The Origin and Spread Of The Early Game
    • The Search for Stability: Baseball and the Voluntary Association as a Cultural Organizing Principle in the Trans-Appalachian West
    • Yankee Pioneers, Merchants, and Missionaries: Cultural Diffusion and the Spread of Baseball
    • The Illusive Nature of Town Ball
  • The Great Match Of Base Ball
  • Civil War Baseball
    • 1861
    • 1862
    • 1863
    • 1864/1865
    • Invited To The Field: A Source-Based Analysis of Baseball in St. Louis During the Civil War
    • The Pioneer Baseball Era in St. Louis and the Civil War
    • The Civil War Reminiscences of General Basil W. Duke, C.S.A.
  • Chris Von der Ahe and the Creation of Modern Baseball
  • The Fall Of Von der Ahe
  • 19th Century St. Louis Baseball Clubs
  • 19th Century St. Louis Baseball Grounds
  • Protoball Stuff
  • Research Links
  • Published Work
  • Contact Me

Von der Ahe Was Elated For Some Reason

3/2/2017

0 Comments

 
President Von der Ahe returned home from the League meeting highly elated over the results of his trip.  He thinks that [Lou] Bierbauer and [Bill] Hutchinson will prove of great aid to the team.  

Chris' Claims.

In speaking of the [Duke] Esper case Chris said: "I never waived claim to Esper, but instead went after him the minute I heard of his release.  The claims of a National League club are always first respected in a case of this kind.  Mark my words, Esper will play with the St. Louis team this year or not play at all.  I paid Pittsburg $1500 for Bierbauer, and I think that he will be worth that much to me.  He is a fine fielder, and while only a fair sticker, has always been regarded as batting opportunely.  Bierbauer will be placed on second base, with Hartman on third and Cross at short.  Dowd, Sullivan and Turner will constitute the outfield.  Either Connor or Douglass will cover first base, and the battery men are plenty strong enough."

-Sporting Life, March 20, 1897 
 

So the big acquisitions of the off-season were Bierbauer, Hutchinson, and Esper.  Von der Ahe wasn't exactly putting together the '27 Yankees.   
0 Comments

Sportsman's Park Almost Burned Down In 1897

3/1/2017

0 Comments

 
More hard luck for President Von der Ahe.  Part of the stabling of his Sportsman's Park took fire Sunday night.  Race track, base ball park, shoot the chutes and summer garden came within an ace of being swept off the face of the earth.  The firemen managed to confine the flames to the stables.  The stables were insured for $2500, but the policies ran out two weeks ago.  The loss to the St. Louis president is about $1500.  

​-Sporting Life, February 27, 1897

And it would all burn down in 1898.  Then, as in 1897, Von der Ahe would not have the insurance to cover his loses.  
0 Comments

Help Is On The Way?

2/28/2017

0 Comments

 
Stanley Robison, vice president of the Cleveland Baseball Club, passed through [St. Louis] on Friday, en route from Hot Springs to Cleveland.  Robison said that the League clubs would have to come to the aid of Von der Ahe.  He added that four of the Eastern League clubs would, at the coming meeting of the League, each turn over a player to the Cleveland Club, and the latter would in turn give to Von der Ahe a quartette of its stars.  The League magnates realize that St. Louis is one of the best drawing cities in the circuit and are fast growing tired of the continued poor teams Von der Ahe puts in the field.  There is little doubt here that the Robisons have arranged to become financially interested in the St. Louis Club.  

-Sporting Life, February 27, 1897


This is a really interesting article and I have no idea how much of it is true.  We'll see but I have no idea if this plan to transfer players from the Eastern clubs to Cleveland and then four players from Cleveland to the Browns took place.  I doubt it but we'll see.  

The other thing that stands out is the idea that the Robisons had a financial interest in the Browns.  I take that to mean that they were investing money in the club but I don't know if that's true either.  I don't think I've ever seen anything about the Robisons investing in the Browns.  
I guess the writer could mean that the Robisons were interested in the financial health of the club but that's not how I read it.  Obviously, they were interested in the market and in the health of the market.  They would try to buy the club in the summer of 1898.  There was obvious interest there.  But I don't see anything in my notes about the Robisons having any financial involvement in St. Louis baseball prior to 1899.       
0 Comments

Von der Ahe Identifies The Cleveland Players He Was After

2/27/2017

0 Comments

 
President Von der Ahe and Secretary Muckenfuss, of the St. Louis Base Ball Club, attended the ladies' bicycle race at the Natatorium one night last week.  Mr. Von der Ahe told a Globe-Democrat representative that the base ball situation, as far as St. Louis was concerned, had not changed whatever.  "I fear that all my efforts to strengthen the Browns," said he, "will come to naught.  While in Cleveland recently I asked President Robison to put a price on three of his players, and if it was anywhere near fair I would buy.  Two of the players I wanted were shortstop McKean and second baseman Childs.  The other was a pitcher.  He refused absolutely to part with either of the trio.  I have made strong efforts to secure strong, seasoned players for my team, but good ball players are not for sale.  Tommy Dowd writes me that he is well satisfied with the players I have under contract, and is confident that he will be able to make them play ball."

-Sporting Life, February 27, 1898


So I was right about the second baseman but wrong about the shortstop.

What's fascinating is that the 1897 Browns were so bad that the addition of Cupid Childs wouldn't really have helped the team much.  He, by himself, wouldn't have been enough to get the club out of last place.  Ed McKean would have been replacing Monte Cross, who, in 1897, was the Browns' best player.  If Von der Ahe made this move and played Childs at second and a combination of Cross and McKean at short and third, the team would have been better but probably still a last place club.  

This club really needed pitching.  A couple of above average pitchers, an upgrade at second, and an upgrade at one of the outfield spots is what this team really needed.
  
0 Comments

Giving Up Hope

2/23/2017

3 Comments

 
President Von der Ahe has about given up all hope of being able to make a deal with the Cleveland and Cincinnati Clubs for the "transfer" of several of their extra players to this city.  He has now turned his attention toward the Eastern clubs, and at the coming meeting of the League magnates in Baltimore he will endeavor to make a trade of some kind for a second baseman and a shortstop.

...With two new infielders and a little strengthening in the pitching department the Browns may manage to keep out of last hole this year.  Otherwise they are doomed to that position, sure.  

-Sporting Life, February 20, 1897


In 1897, the Browns finished twenty-three and a half games out of eleventh place.  If they had brought in Kid Nichols, Hugh Jennings, and George Davis, they probably would have escaped the cellar.  Maybe.  And I don't even want to contemplate what you'd have to bring in to make up the sixty-four games they'd need to win the pennant.    
3 Comments

Robison Wanted The Earth

2/22/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Earth for Cy Young, Cupid Childs, and Bobby Wallace. Throw in the Moon and you can have Jack Powell.
Apparently Mr. Von der Ahe's visit to Cleveland and Cincinnati has had no practiced result.  Chris himself says that no deal had been made with either Brush or Robison, but he admitted that he tried to secure a shortstop, second baseman and pitcher from Cleveland.  "Robison wanted the earth," was the way Von der Ahe explained his failure to bring three of the crack players back with him.  

​-Sporting Life, February 13, 1897

​So...Bobby Wallace could play short, even though he played mostly third base in 1896 and 1897.  The second baseman had to be Cupid Childs.  And the pitcher had to be Cy Young, right?  I'd probably go with the young Jack Powell over the 30 year old Young but, really, Cy Young had a better career going forward from 1897 on than the 22 year old Powell did.  That's shocking but true.

Regardless, this is Von der Ahe's account of what he was doing on the trip and all the rumors surrounding it, that we've already mentioned, were probably just nonsense.  Although, Sporting Life goes kind of mention all of that when it reported, in this same issue, that Stanley Robison arrived in St. Louis shortly after Von der Ahe did.  It appears Robison went to Sportsman's Park and had a meeting with Von der Ahe.  What they talked about we don't know.  Was Von der Ahe trying to buy the Clevelands?  Was he just trying to work out some kind of trade?  Was Robison trying to buy the Browns?  Nobody knows but the odds are that it was simply a matter of Von der Ahe trying to negotiate some kind of deal for a few of the Cleveland players.  
    
0 Comments

Getting Out Of The Horse Racing Game

2/20/2017

0 Comments

 
Base ball and horse racing does not mix.  Chirs Von der Ahe, president of the St. Louis Browns, has found this out, and he has decided to give up the management of his turf enterprise.  The chief of "Der Browns" reached this conclusion last Wednesday, when he declared off the races at Sportsman's Park, and leased the grounds, privileges and everything else inside the inclosure to another man, one Louis Cella, a bookmaker.  From now on the most talked-of man in sporting circles will confine his efforts to base ball and to his "shoot the chutes" and other summer resort enterprises.  The race track will not be a dead weight on the St. Louis chief.  On the contrary, if the new lessees are successful in drawing the people to the park and getting enough bookmakers to draw on, they will pay Chris a rental of $1000 a week.

-Sporting Life, January 2, 1897

I know I'm jumping around here but I wanted to get some of this stuff on record before I forgot about it.  I had mentioned the stuff about the club never losing money except for 1890 and Von der Ahe getting rid of the racetrack and just wanted to document all of that.  The off-season stuff is always full of interesting information like this, as well as tons of specious rumors.  So we have to forge through this before we can soak in the schadenfreude of the 1897 season itself.  
0 Comments

We Have Gotten Over Our Worst Days

2/17/2017

0 Comments

 
Von der Ahe acknowledges that there was only one year in all his experience as a magnate in which he lost money on base ball.  That was during the Brotherhood year.  And in the future he promises to stick entirely to base ball and become a pillar in the church.  This change in Chris' temperament is accounted for by an interview which appeared in the "Republic" the other day, in which a director of the St. Louis Club says:

"We buried about $40,000 in the chutes, which, all stories to the contrary, paid us about 25 per cent. on the investment.  That leaves us still $30,000 in the hole on the chute question.  Then we paid Fred Foster $42,000 for his interest in that track, and we lost some money running the races in opposition to other tracks.  Oh, we had a mazy time of it when we went against the racing game.  I think that we will make money out of the chutes, and we have it fixed so that we will not lose another cent on the race track, so I think we have gotten over our worst days."

It is hoped that this is true and that the St. Louis Club will use some of its profits in the future purchasing new players.

-Sporting Life, January 23, 1897
I have quoted Von der Ahe on numerous occasions stating that the Browns made money every year except for 1890 and here we have the source of that information.  I have this somewhere in my disorganized notes but came across it again the other day while going through the January 1897 issues of Sporting Life.  The article also quotes the claim that the club made $12,000 in 1896.  

We also have Von der Ahe's ironic statement that his worst financial days were behind him.  This would prove not to be correct.
   
0 Comments

More On The Potential Cleveland Deal

2/16/2017

0 Comments

 
Secretary Muir of the Cleveland club has given out the following statement:

"Mr. Robison would rather sell the club entire than sell or exchange any one of his star players, but he will not sell the club..."

In reference to the stoy that Von der Ahe's visit was for the purpose of purchasing six of Cleveland's men, Mr Robison says that it was the worst fake of many fakes this year.  "Why do you suppose," said Mr. Robison, "that Von der Ahe, who sold his best player for a cash consideration, would expend money in bolstering up his team?  Besides Mr. Von der Ahe has made no proposition of this nature to me, and until he does I can say nothing."

-Evening Star (Washington, D.C.), February 4, 1897

Chris Von der Ahe of the St. Louis Base Ball Club and President John T. Brush held a private conference at Indianapolis yesterday.  Neither cared to talk of the details of the meeting.  President Brush said that Mr. Von der Ahe wanted to strengthen his club and needed some assistance.  Several deals were discussed.  The most important one was the purchase of the Cleveland Club.  Mr. Von der Ahe went to Cleveland several days ago prepared to make an offer for several crack players of that club, and his visit to Indianapolis was for the purpose of securing President Bush's co-operation in buying out the club, dividing the players and putting a National League Club in Indianapolis.  

Mr. Von der Ahe would neither affirm nor deny this feature of the case, but did say that he was after ball players, and was going to get them in whatever way he could, even if he had to buy another club.  

President Brush said that such a deal could not be made without the consent of the other clubs in the league.  Von der Ahe left for St. Louis this afternoon.

-Evening Star (Washington D.C.), February 5, 1897


I have no clue if any of this is true or not but it sure is interesting.  

So Von der Ahe was in Cleveland in an attempt to either buy several of the Cleveland players or, failing that, to buy the entire club, with the financial assistance of Brush.  The Cleveland club would cease to exist, the Browns would take some of their players, and the rest would form the core of a new League club in Indianapolis.  It all sounds a bit too complicated to be true but I guess it's possible.  

The irony of all of this is that Robison would try and purchase the St. Louis club in the summer of 1898 and would, essentially, get control of that club prior to the 1899 season.  He would bring his Cleveland players to St. Louis and send the St. Louis players to Cleveland.  Given that that actually happened two years later, maybe there was something to this Von der Ahe/Brush/Cleveland rumor.  Given all of the weirdness that would happen, why not this?
   
0 Comments

No Agreement Was Reached

2/15/2017

0 Comments

 
President Von der Ahe, of the St. Louis base ball team, who arrived [in Cleveland] yesterday afternoon, continued his conference with President Robison of the Cleveland club to-day.  The two magnates were in earnest conversation throughout the morning and until 2 o'clock this afternoon, when President Von der Ahe left the city, presumably for St. Louis.  It is known that the St. Louis president came here principally for the purpose of negotiating for players to strengthen his club, but just before his departure this afternoon he and Mr. Robison both declared that no agreement had been reached and Mr. Robison added that it was safe to say there would be no base ball deal as a result of President Von der Ahe's visit to Cleveland.  It is understood that Von der Ahe made several different offers in the way of trades and bonuses for certain Cleveland players, but that in no case did the inducements held out meet the views of Mr. Robison.

-Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, February 4, 1897


The 1897 Clevelands were a pretty good club and, of course, plenty of those guys would end up playing in St. Louis in 1899.  They had some good young players such as a twenty-three year old Bobby Wallace and twenty-two year old Jack Powell that could have helped the Browns.  But if I had to guess, I'd say that Von der Ahe was trying to get Patsy Tebeau.  
0 Comments
<<Previous
    Welcome to This Game Of Games, a website dedicated to telling the story of 19th century, St. Louis baseball.  

    Search TGOG
    search engine by freefind

    Categories

    All
    1859
    1860
    1861
    1862
    1863
    1864
    1865
    1866
    1867
    1868
    1869
    1870
    1874
    1875
    1877
    1880
    1881
    1883
    1884
    1885 World Series
    1886 World Series
    1887 World Series
    1897
    Abbey Grounds
    Abraham Lincoln
    Actives
    Adam Wirth
    Adolphus Busch
    Advance
    Adventures
    Aetnas
    Alex Crosman
    Alfred Bernoudy
    Alma
    Al Spink
    Alton
    American Association
    Andy Blong
    Anheuser-Busch
    Arlie Latham
    Artisans
    Asa Smith
    Athletics
    Atlantics
    Augustus Charles Bernays
    Augustus Solari
    Avian Homicide
    Ballparks
    Baltics
    Basil Duke
    Beer
    Belleville
    Benjamin Muckenfuss
    Benton Barracks
    BFIB
    Bill Hague
    Bill Hallman
    Bill Hutchinson
    Billy Redmond
    Black Baseball
    Bluff City
    Bob Caruthers
    Bremen
    Browns
    Brown Stockings
    Brown Stockings
    Camp Jackson
    Cardinals
    Carondelet
    Cbc
    Charles Comiskey
    Charles Fowle
    Charles Hunt Turner
    Charles Kearny
    Charles Paul
    Charles Scudder
    Charles Spink
    Charleston
    Charles Turner
    Charlie Houtz
    Charlie Sweasy
    Charlie Sweeney
    Charlie Waitt
    Chris Von Der Ahe
    Collinsville
    Commercial Juniors
    Commercials
    C. Orrick Bishop
    Cranky Old Man
    Cricket
    Curt Welch
    Cyclones
    Dan Devinney
    Dave Foutz
    Dave Rowe
    David Reid
    Davy Force
    Denny Mack
    Dickey Pearce
    Diregos
    Doc Bushong
    Duff Cooley
    Duke Esper
    Dusty Miller
    East St. Louis
    Eclipse
    E.C. Simmons
    Eddie Fusselback
    Edgar Noe
    Edward Becker
    Edward Bredell
    Edward Finney
    Edwardsville
    Edwin Fowler
    Eh Tobias9483ebbf42
    Elephants
    Empire-juniors
    Empires
    Enterprise
    Equipment
    Excelsior Juniors
    Excelsiors
    Female Baseball
    Ferdinand Garesche
    Frank Billon
    Frank Ellis
    Frank Fleet
    Frank Robison
    Fred Dunlap
    Frederick Benteen
    Gamble Lawn
    Genghis Khan
    George Bradley
    George Knapp
    George McManus
    George Miller
    George Munson
    George Paynter
    German
    Grand Avenue Grounds
    Greenville
    Griff Prather
    Grounds
    Gus Schmelz
    Gustave Gruner
    Harry Diddlebock
    Harvard
    Heinie Peitz
    Henry Clay Sexton
    Henry Gratiot
    Henry Lucas
    Herman Dehlman
    Hermann
    Hickory
    Holly Hall
    Hope
    Ice Box Chamberlain
    Imperial Jrs.
    Imperials
    Independents
    Israelites
    Jack Boyle
    Jack Gleason
    Jack McGeachey
    Jackson Grounds
    Jake Murray
    James Foster
    James Pennoyer
    James Spaulding
    James Yule
    J.B.C. Lucas
    Jeremiah Fruin
    Jerry Denny
    Jimmy Bannon
    Joe Battin
    Joe Blong
    Joe Ellick
    Joe Franklin
    Joe Schimper
    John Berry
    John Clapp
    John Henry
    John Newell
    John Peters
    John Riggin
    John Shockey
    John Young
    Joseph Carr
    Joseph Charless Cabanne
    Joseph Gamble
    Joseph Hollenback
    Joseph Ketterer
    Joseph Scott Fullerton
    J.P. Freeman
    J.P. Riechers & Sons
    Julius Smith
    Jumbo McGinnis
    Kansas
    Kid Carsey
    Lacledes
    Lafayette Park
    Lebanon
    Leonard Matthews
    Liberty
    Lip Pike
    Lone Stars
    Lou Bierbauer
    Magnolias
    Mark Baldwin
    Maroons
    Martin Burke
    Martin Collins
    Mase Graffen
    Maurice Alexander
    McKendree College
    Merritt Griswold
    Mike McGeary
    Mississippi BBC
    Missouri BBC
    Missouri History Museum
    Morning Stars
    Mutuals
    Mystics
    Nathaniel Lyons
    Nationals
    Native American Ball Games
    Ned Cuthbert
    Niagaras
    O'Fallon
    Old Weird America
    Olympics
    Origins
    Orville Matthews
    Packy Dillon
    Parson Nicholson
    Patsy Tebeau
    Peerless
    Perfectos
    Pidge Morgan
    Polar Stars
    Professionalism
    Protoball
    Pud Galvin
    Quincy
    Reds
    Reeb's Station
    Resolute
    Richard Perry
    Robert Henry
    Robert Lucas
    Robert Niggeman
    Roger Connor
    Rudy Kemmler
    Rufus Gamble
    Sedalia
    Shepard Barclay
    Shurtleff College
    Silver Flint
    Silver King
    Stanley Robison
    St. Charles
    Ste. Genevieve
    St. Louis BBC
    St. Louis University
    Stonewalls
    Sunday Baseball
    Ted Breitenstein
    Ted Sullivan
    The Baldwin Affair
    The Championship Of The West
    The Civil War
    The Cyclone Thesis
    The Illinois Country
    The Interregnum
    The West
    The Willie McGee Game
    Thomas Mcneary
    Tigers
    Tip O'Neill
    Tom-loftus
    Tom Miller
    Tom Oran
    Tony-mullane
    Town Ball
    Trick Mcsorley
    Troy
    Turners
    Uniforms
    Union-grounds
    Union-juniors
    Unions
    Unknown-club
    Veto-grounds
    W.A. Kelsoe
    Wallace-delafield
    Washington-university
    Wayman-crow-mccreery
    Wc Steigers0bee5fa822
    Whites
    Wicket
    William-faulkner
    William Greenleaf
    William-pennoyer
    William-spink
    William-t-sherman
    Willis-walker
    Young-commercials
    Young-union-juniors

    RSS Feed

    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Powered by
✕