Contact me
  • Home
  • Why "This Game Of Games"?
  • What's Up With That Rooster?
  • The Old Blog
  • Henry Gratiot and Early St. Louis Ball-Playing
  • Baseball In The Illinois Country
  • Thoughts On The Origin and Spread Of The Early Game
    • The Search for Stability: Baseball and the Voluntary Association as a Cultural Organizing Principle in the Trans-Appalachian West
    • Yankee Pioneers, Merchants, and Missionaries: Cultural Diffusion and the Spread of Baseball
    • The Illusive Nature of Town Ball
  • The Great Match Of Base Ball
  • Civil War Baseball
    • 1861
    • 1862
    • 1863
    • 1864/1865
    • Invited To The Field: A Source-Based Analysis of Baseball in St. Louis During the Civil War
    • The Pioneer Baseball Era in St. Louis and the Civil War
    • The Civil War Reminiscences of General Basil W. Duke, C.S.A.
  • Chris Von der Ahe and the Creation of Modern Baseball
  • The Fall Of Von der Ahe
  • 19th Century St. Louis Baseball Clubs
  • 19th Century St. Louis Baseball Grounds
  • Protoball Stuff
  • Research Links
  • Published Work
  • Contact Me

Thomas McNeary's 1875 Letter to the Clipper

8/28/2015

0 Comments

 
Blong and McSorley of the St. Louis Red Stocking nine have been expelled from that club, as will be seen from the appended letter:

Editor New York Clipper. - Last week the St. Louis "Reds" got ready to go to Quincy, Ill., to play a couple of games, and they went; but the third-baseman, John McSorley, failed to be on hand to accompany the club.  And since returning from Quincy, I have learned that McSorley, like Blong, had jumped from St. Louis to the Stars of Covington; and, as both of the players mentioned have been expelled from the St. Louis "Reds." This is to notify other clubs that neither of the players can be engaged next year, unless reinstated by the Judiciary Committee of the Professional Association.  The St. Louis "Reds" will remain in existence until the close of the season, and next year they will be in the field again.  Very Respectfully,

Thomas McNeary, Prest. St. Louis "Reds."

-New York Clipper, September 11, 1875
This is just fantastic.  There is nothing in this letter that's new and I've seen all of this information in the contemporary source material before.  However, I don't think I've ever seen this specific letter before and I can't remember seeing anything like this from McNeary.  

The context of the letter is that Joe Blong, Trick McSorely and Packy Dillon had all left the Reds, in the middle of the 1875 season, for the Covington Stars.  Charlie Sweasy, the captain, would also leave the club in September.  The Reds just didn't make any money in 1875 and the players were being paid a percentage of the gate.  The team wasn't winning; they weren't drawing fans; and the players weren't making any money.  So a lot of them left.  The entire thing had fallen apart by the first week of July, when Blong left.  The Reds were unable to schedule any more games against clubs in the National Association and were forced to play lesser clubs, such as Quincy.  

The whole thing was a bit of a disaster and here we have Tom McNeary trying to see that some form of justice was enacted against his former players.  Nothing ever really came of that but I think McNeary was certainly within his rights to see the National Association punish the jumpers.     
0 Comments

Treated Most Cavalierly

8/27/2015

0 Comments

 
The St. Louis Browns, the champion base-ball club of the West, has just sustained a damaging defeat at the hands of the Bostons.  The Browns were treated most cavalierly throughout the entire game. 

-Cairo Bulletin, July 23, 1875
I thought it was kind of interesting to see the Brown Stockings getting some attention from a Southern Illinois paper.  I don't know why I find it interesting, except to say that I found it unexpected.  Also of interest here is the reference to the club as the "Browns," a name that we preserve for later St. Louis clubs but one that was in common use at the time, as well as the reference to the club as the champions of the West, a title that, I imagine, they were awarded based upon their victories over the Chicagos. 

The games in question here were played in Boston on July 19 and 21 and the Brown Stockings lost 7-2 and 16-6.  I guess it was the fact that the Brown Stockings were playing the great Boston Red Stockings that captured the attention of the Cairo paper.     
0 Comments

1875: How They Stand

2/21/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Taking a quick look at the NA standings, as of May 15, 1875 and published in the Republican on May 16, we find that the Brown Stockings were 5-0 and the Reds were 1-4.  The Browns were heading to Chicago for a couple of games, starting on May 19, while the Reds wouldn't play another NA game until the 21st, at home against Keokuk, before they, too, headed off to Chicago for a couple of games against the Whites.  
0 Comments

1875: A Very Agreeable Surprise

2/20/2014

0 Comments

 
The Brown Stockings were the recipients of a very agreeable surprise last evening, in the shape of an elegant supper at Sides' restaurant, in commemoration of their well-earned victories over the Chicago club.  After the repast, which was replete with all the delicacies of the season, a social hour was passed in congratulatory speeches and songs by the club glee.  A substantial token of the club's appreciation of the players' good conduct on and off the field was found upon each plate set apart for the boys who wear the brown.  


-St. Louis Republican, May 16, 1875
So the Brown Stockings had a glee club.  That's news to me and I'm going to let it slide.

Also of note, I have to assume that the substantial token of appreciation was cash money.   
0 Comments

1875: Behind The Scenes Wrangling

2/19/2014

0 Comments

 
In our edition of Monday last we reported that the game between the Empires and White Stockings was "off."  Our reasons therefor were Mr. Wood's statement to that effect made on Sunday evening - he stated distinctly to Mr. Pike of the Brown Stockings that the Empres' committee had talked of a game, and were to have made arrangements with him on Sunday afternoon, but failed to call as agreed upon and as Mr. McNeary had complained that it was injuring the games arranged with his club on Tuesday and Thursday - he had concluded not to play.  We know further that the White Stockings' players were so instructed, Messrs. Zettlein and Glenn informing our reporter to that effect as late as eleven o'clock on Monday morning.  It is to be regretted, but the fault lays with Mr. Wood and the directors of the Empire club, not with us.

-St. Louis Republican, May 16, 1875
I believe that McNeary's concerns about an Empire/Chicago game hurting the gate for Reds/Chicago games was the deciding factor in calling off the game.  And it's very interesting that this kind of wrangling was going on behind the scenes.  It gives us a nice sense of what was happening to the Reds and the kinds of problems that they were already running into, as they struggled both on the field and at the gate in their short-lived professional, championship existence.  It's also rather interesting that the Chicagos took those concerns seriously and adjusted their schedule to try and address them.  
0 Comments

1875: Settling An Unfounded Rumor

2/18/2014

0 Comments

 
Much comment has been made about a decision of the umpire Mr. Mack in the game played at Keokuk on the 13th inst., between the Brown Stockings and Westerns.  Mr. Mack's card below, will at once settle the unfounded rumor of his admitting making an erroneous decision.

St. Louis, May 15, 1875.
Editor St. Louis Republican - Dear Sir:  In the Keokuk papers of the 14th inst., and in a telegraphic report of the game played in that town on Thursday last, I had the honor to officiate as umpire, and am represented as "making an erroneous decision and afterwards admitting it."  I simply desire to say that my belief at the time was in accordance with the decision given and subsequent investigation have satisfied me that the same was entirely correct.  Yours truly,  D. Mack.

-St. Louis Republican, May 16, 1875
I'm not sure what all the hubbub was about and don't see anything in the Republican's game account about any controversy but I just like the fact that Mr. Mack, who was a member of the Empire Club, felt the need to address the situation.  It's such a 19th century kind of thing.  
0 Comments

1875: Some Fishing And Four Unearned Runs Make For A Good Day

2/17/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Keokuk, May 13. - "Old Probs" again favored us with a pretty day, as, barring the high wind, it was a delightful day for out-door sports.

In the morning the boys took a walk across the bridge and fished, or rather tried to catch some of the finny tribe, but without any satisfactory results - Pike being the only one to land one of his namesakes.  Battin got up a momentary excitement by tying the one Lip. had caught to his line, quietly dropping it in the water and pulling it out with a great shout, but the rick was too thin and only lasted until Pike went to compare it with his prize.

After dinner the bus was loaded and at half-past two we were upon the field of green for our second tussle with the doughty Westerns.  Capt. Dicky again called the lucky side of the nickel and took his men into the field, Mr. Mack again officiating as umpire.  It was soon apparent that the Iowa champions were not going to let us have the soft thing of yesterday over again.  Golden pitched throughout the entire game with more attention to strategy and less to speed, and Barnie backed him up with more vim and accuracy.  The fielders also played with more ease and steadiness.  Up to the fifth innings but one run had been made, that by the Westerns, and the Browns began to realize that a nice piece of work was cut out for them to get another ball away from Keokuk.  After whitewashing their opponents in the fifth innings, the Browns got in two unearned runs, Dehlman by a good fair-foul for two bases and good base running made third, stealing home on Cuthbert's high hit to centre field; Pearce being sent around by Pike after making first on an error.

Two unearned runs in the seventh and eighth innings, however, gave the Browns the lead and game, as the Blue Stockings failed to get nearer home than third base, where Carbine was left in the eighth innings.

The game was hotly contested, and the playing on both sides first-class.  Hague and Pearce were charged with most errors on the winning side, but both made brilliant plays that offset them.  

On the part of the Westerns, Carbine, Hallinan and Barnie deserve special mention for efficient service in the field.  The former and Goldsmith leading at the bat.

-St. Louis Republican, May 15, 1875
0 Comments

1875: An Increased Excitement In The Fraternity

2/14/2014

0 Comments

 
The return game of the Western with our Browns yesterday, proving a much closer one than that of the day previous, was the cause of an increased excitement in the fraternity in St. Louis.  When at the end of the sixth inning the city bulletin-board showed a tie of two runs, the excitement reached its climax.  The final score of 4 to 2 in favor of St. Louis...is the best that Keokuk has yet produced and is withal one of the best games of the season.  All attempts to sell pools yesterday either on the Red-White game or the Brown-Western, proved unavailing.  Men with change in their pockets are beginning to understand that it is risky staking it on base ball.  On Saturday night pools will be sold for the next Chicago-St. Louis match, which takes place in Chicago next Wednesday.

On Saturday the Browns and Reds will play their second game at the Grand Avenue park.  Bradley is recovering, and will probably be well enough for the game, but Fleet will probably pitch for practice.  The boys will be home to-night.

-St. Louis Republican, May 14, 1875
The May 15th game between the Brown Stockings and Reds, mentioned by the Republican, never came off and I look forward to discovering the reason why.  It was probably a result of weather but it's possible that, even at this early date, the Reds were finding it difficult to schedule other NA clubs.  We'll see.  
0 Comments

1875: A Hard-Fought And Well-Earned Victory

2/13/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Keokuk, May 13. - The weather to-day was very fine and the playing in keeping with it.  The attendance was melancholy, about one hundred and fifty persons being all that turned out to witness one of the best played games of the season.  The Browns again won the toss and sent their opponents to the bat, both nines being the same as yesterday.  Mutual blanks were exchanged in the first two innings, the fielding being of the sharpest kind.  One run was scored by the Westerns in the third innings by an error of Hague and a base hit of Jones.  Another, and their all, was earned in the sixth by good hits of Hollihan and Goldsmith.  The Browns scored two in the fifth by a two-base hit of Dehlman, and a single by Pike.  Pearce scored one on the latter's hit, after making first on Joe Miller's error.  The playing of the Westerns was first-class, Golden's pitching being a great improvement on yesterday's, and Barnie having but one passed ball.  It was a hard-fought and well-earned victory for the Browns, who supported Fleet splendidly.

-St. Louis Republican, May 14, 1875
0 Comments

1875: The Only Ray Of Comfort

2/12/2014

0 Comments

 
The Chicagos left at 7 last night for the Garden city.  The game of yesterday was the only ray of comfort they took home with them.  The story they will tell at home will be this.  The Browns beat us accidentally one very bad game, the Reds almost did the same thing.  Both clubs are about equal.  We proved that it was accidental by our victory of 15 to 2 over the Reds.  We can do the same to the Browns when next we meet them.  The Chicago trick is to declare that the Reds whom they beat are the equals of the Browns whom they didn't beat.  We hope they will draw comfort from this view for they certainly need it, but the Browns are very likely to spoil even this little theory next week.

-St. Louis Republican, May 14, 1875 
0 Comments
<<Previous
    Welcome to This Game Of Games, a website dedicated to telling the story of 19th century, St. Louis baseball.  

    Search TGOG
    search engine by freefind

    Categories

    All
    1859
    1860
    1861
    1862
    1863
    1864
    1865
    1866
    1867
    1868
    1869
    1870
    1874
    1875
    1877
    1880
    1881
    1883
    1884
    1885 World Series
    Abbey Grounds
    Abraham Lincoln
    Actives
    Adam Wirth
    Adolphus Busch
    Advance
    Adventures
    Aetnas
    Alex Crosman
    Alfred Bernoudy
    Alma
    Al Spink
    Alton
    American Association
    Andy Blong
    Anheuser-Busch
    Arlie Latham
    Artisans
    Asa Smith
    Athletics
    Atlantics
    Augustus Charles Bernays
    Augustus Solari
    Avian Homicide
    Ballparks
    Baltics
    Basil Duke
    Beer
    Belleville
    Benjamin Muckenfuss
    Benton Barracks
    BFIB
    Bill Hague
    Billy Redmond
    Black Baseball
    Bluff City
    Bob Caruthers
    Bremen
    Browns
    Brown Stockings
    Brown Stockings
    Camp Jackson
    Cardinals
    Carondelet
    Cbc
    Charles Comiskey
    Charles Fowle
    Charles Hunt Turner
    Charles Kearny
    Charles Paul
    Charles Scudder
    Charles Spink
    Charles Turner
    Charlie Houtz
    Charlie Sweasy
    Charlie Sweeney
    Charlie Waitt
    Chris Von Der Ahe
    Collinsville
    Commercial Juniors
    Commercials
    C. Orrick Bishop
    Cranky Old Man
    Cricket
    Curt Welch
    Cyclones
    Dan Devinney
    Dave Foutz
    David Reid
    Davy Force
    Denny Mack
    Dickey Pearce
    Diregos
    Duff Cooley
    Dusty Miller
    East St. Louis
    Eclipse
    E.C. Simmons
    Eddie Fusselback
    Edgar Noe
    Edward Becker
    Edward Bredell
    Edward Finney
    Edwardsville
    Edwin Fowler
    Eh Tobias9483ebbf42
    Elephants
    Empire-juniors
    Empires
    Enterprise
    Equipment
    Excelsior Juniors
    Excelsiors
    Female Baseball
    Ferdinand Garesche
    Frank Billon
    Frank Ellis
    Frank Fleet
    Frank Robison
    Fred Dunlap
    Frederick Benteen
    Gamble Lawn
    George Bradley
    George Knapp
    George McManus
    George Miller
    George Munson
    George Paynter
    Grand Avenue Grounds
    Greenville
    Griff Prather
    Grounds
    Gus Schmelz
    Gustave Gruner
    Harry Diddlebock
    Heinie Peitz
    Henry Clay Sexton
    Henry Gratiot
    Henry Lucas
    Herman Dehlman
    Hermann
    Hickory
    Holly Hall
    Hope
    Ice Box Chamberlain
    Imperial Jrs.
    Imperials
    Independents
    Israelites
    Jack Gleason
    Jack McGeachey
    Jackson Grounds
    Jake Murray
    James Foster
    James Pennoyer
    James Spaulding
    James Yule
    J.B.C. Lucas
    Jeremiah Fruin
    Jerry Denny
    Jimmy Bannon
    Joe Battin
    Joe Blong
    Joe Ellick
    Joe Franklin
    Joe Schimper
    John Berry
    John Clapp
    John Henry
    John Peters
    John Riggin
    John Shockey
    John Young
    Joseph Carr
    Joseph Charless Cabanne
    Joseph Gamble
    Joseph Hollenback
    Joseph Ketterer
    Joseph Scott Fullerton
    J.P. Freeman
    J.P. Riechers & Sons
    Julius Smith
    Jumbo McGinnis
    Kansas
    Lacledes
    Lafayette Park
    Lebanon
    Leonard Matthews
    Liberty
    Lip Pike
    Lone Stars
    Magnolias
    Mark Baldwin
    Maroons
    Martin Burke
    Martin Collins
    Mase Graffen
    Maurice Alexander
    McKendree College
    Merritt Griswold
    Mike McGeary
    Mississippi BBC
    Missouri BBC
    Missouri History Museum
    Morning Stars
    Mutuals
    Mystics
    Nathaniel Lyons
    Nationals
    Native American Ball Games
    Ned Cuthbert
    Niagaras
    O'Fallon
    Old Weird America
    Olympics
    Origins
    Orville Matthews
    Packy Dillon
    Parson Nicholson
    Patsy Tebeau
    Peerless
    Perfectos
    Pidge Morgan
    Polar Stars
    Professionalism
    Protoball
    Pud Galvin
    Quincy
    Reds
    Reeb's Station
    Resolute
    Richard Perry
    Robert Henry
    Robert Lucas
    Robert Niggeman
    Roger Connor
    Rudy Kemmler
    Rufus Gamble
    Sedalia
    Shepard Barclay
    Shurtleff College
    Silver Flint
    Silver King
    Stanley Robison
    St. Charles
    Ste. Genevieve
    St. Louis BBC
    St. Louis University
    Stonewalls
    Sunday Baseball
    Ted Breitenstein
    Ted Sullivan
    The Baldwin Affair
    The Championship Of The West
    The Civil War
    The Cyclone Thesis
    The Illinois Country
    The Interregnum
    The West
    The Willie McGee Game
    Thomas Mcneary
    Tigers
    Tom Loftus
    Tom Miller
    Tom Oran
    Tony Mullane
    Town Ball
    Trick Mcsorley
    Troy
    Turners
    Uniforms
    Union Grounds
    Union-juniors
    Unions
    Unknown Club
    Veto-grounds
    Wallace Delafield
    Washington University
    Wayman Crow McCreery
    W.C. Steigers
    Whites
    Wicket
    William-faulkner
    William Greenleaf
    William-pennoyer
    William-spink
    William-t-sherman
    Willis-walker
    Young-commercials
    Young-union-juniors

    RSS Feed

    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Create a free website
Powered by
Create your own free website

Start your own free website

A surprisingly easy drag & drop site creator. Learn more.
✕