It seems that the site where I access the Missouri Republican is down so I can't get to the 1870 issues at the moment. It'll probably be back up sometime today but I don't have the time to wait on it. So 1870 is on hold for the week. How about the 1885 World Series instead?
The first of the series of games between the Chicagos, champion club of the National League, and the St. Louis, champion club of the American Association, for the championship of the world, was played this afternoon [in Chicago], and resulted in a tie in eight innings, though the Chicagos would doubtless have won in the next, as they had just begun to play when game was called. Previous to the game throwing and running contests were held. Williamson threw the ball 133 yards, 1 foot, 4 inches, defeating five others. Pfeffer ran the bases in 15 1/4 seconds, defeating five contestants. The Chicagos sent the visitors to bat, and toyed with them. The runs were made as follows: For the visitors, Comiskey got a base on error and scored on two other errors in the second. In the fourth O'Neill, Robinson, Latham and Caruthers got in runs off of two safe hits and three errors, Kelly scoring. In the eighth Gore got a base on balls, and scored off singles by Kelly and Anson. Pfeffer followed with a home run, and tied the game. The umpire called the game on account of darkness. The two clubs go to St. Louis, Cincinnati, Baltimore, Pittsburg, Philadelphia and Brooklyn.
-St. Louis Globe-Democrat, October 15, 1885
There was very little build-up in the press for this series. I can't even find a mention of it in the Globe in the days leading up to the first game. The Tribune mentions it in a brief paragraph on the day of the game. This is in comparison to the massive coverage that each club received in their respective city papers after they won their league championship, when there were full page spreads about the celebrations in the cities and short biographies and pictures of each of the players. Of course, the goal of each club was to win their respective league and the series was little more than an exhibition but I was surprised at how little press there was in the days before the series started.
One interesting thing of note was that the first two games were played as benefits for the players. The Chicago players split the gate from game one in Chicago and the St. Louis players split the gate from game two in St. Louis. I'm not certain, as of yet, how the rest of the money from the series was divided but I'm assuming it was pocketed by the clubs.